News:

See the Forum Status page for any planned Forum maintenance or alerts on Forum outages.

Main Menu

British Columbia's Highways

Started by jakeroot, January 08, 2021, 01:16:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

splashflash



pderocco

Glad I got to drive the old bridge a year and a half ago. Maybe I'll get to drive the new bridge this summer. I have a pet project to maybe drive all the Fraser River car crossings.

Max Rockatansky

The cable stay design isn't exactly exciting with how many similar spans have been built recently.  The Pattullo Bridge wasn't exactly a looker but through arches are becoming rare.

jakeroot

Quote from: Max Rockatansky on February 21, 2026, 02:49:12 PMThe cable stay design isn't exactly exciting with how many similar spans have been built recently.  The Pattullo Bridge wasn't exactly a looker but through arches are becoming rare.

Couple of Facebook posts I've seen regarding the bridge say as much. "Why do all the Fraser River crossings look the same?" is a common complaint. The Massey Tunnel replacement bridge was to have a similar design, too.

Personally, coming from the land of floating bridges, it's nice to see actual bridge spans that go above water, regardless of design.

splashflash

Quote from: jakeroot on February 21, 2026, 04:35:58 PM
Quote from: Max Rockatansky on February 21, 2026, 02:49:12 PMThe cable stay design isn't exactly exciting with how many similar spans have been built recently.  The Pattullo Bridge wasn't exactly a looker but through arches are becoming rare.

Couple of Facebook posts I've seen regarding the bridge say as much. "Why do all the Fraser River crossings look the same?" is a common complaint. The Massey Tunnel replacement bridge was to have a similar design, too.

Personally, coming from the land of floating bridges, it's nice to see actual bridge spans that go above water, regardless of design.

Remaining non cable span bridges across the Fraser include the Mission Bridge (below) and Fraser Bridge at Hope.


Mission Bridge with CP Rail bridge in the background.


Bridge in Hope.  Originally double deck with railway on bottom deck.




TXtoNJ

#155

Making travel easier with new Highway 11 interchange under construction by Province of  British Columbia, on Flickr

As suspected, the design for the Highway 11 interchange is no longer the DDI concept. Instead, it'll be a modified diamond with one cloverleaf.

stevashe

Quote from: TXtoNJ on April 09, 2026, 10:57:38 PM
Making travel easier with new Highway 11 interchange under construction by Province of  British Columbia, on Flickr

As suspected, the design for the Highway 11 interchange is no longer the DDI concept. Instead, it'll be a modified diamond with one cloverleaf.

That's... interesting. It's like a cross between a SPUI and a parclo.

TXtoNJ

Quote from: stevashe on April 10, 2026, 11:17:25 AM
Quote from: TXtoNJ on April 09, 2026, 10:57:38 PM
Making travel easier with new Highway 11 interchange under construction by Province of  British Columbia, on Flickr

As suspected, the design for the Highway 11 interchange is no longer the DDI concept. Instead, it'll be a modified diamond with one cloverleaf.

That's... interesting. It's like a cross between a SPUI and a parclo.

It makes sense in that movements here are very unbalanced. There's a large industrial zone along with the US border to the south, meaning that most truck traffic will be making south and west movements. However, the bulk of Abbotsford's population lies north and west of the interchange, so those movements need to be accounted for as well.

Eastbound movements towards Chilliwack and Hope are more often served by the McCallum Rd and Whatcom Rd interchanges, which is why I think they moved away from the DDI concept. This also provides more space for the new truck parking there.

Rest stops and park-and-rides are particularly controversial in this area, as they've been mainly used by squatters in RVs for the past decade or so. Supportive housing exists ~200 m to the west, across the railway tracks, so moving the truck parking here would be a compromise most people in the area would accept.

jakeroot

I am surprised they're not building a partial cloverleaf of some kind. Specifically the B4 style with off-ramp loops. It would have allowed constant flow off Hwy 1 in all directions, and the left turns onto Hwy 1 could be tied into the existing intersections. It would have allowed for that truck parking area, too.

TXtoNJ

Quote from: jakeroot on April 11, 2026, 12:55:26 AMI am surprised they're not building a partial cloverleaf of some kind. Specifically the B4 style with off-ramp loops. It would have allowed constant flow off Hwy 1 in all directions, and the left turns onto Hwy 1 could be tied into the existing intersections. It would have allowed for that truck parking area, too.
Quote from: jakeroot on April 11, 2026, 12:55:26 AMI am surprised they're not building a partial cloverleaf of some kind. Specifically the B4 style with off-ramp loops. It would have allowed constant flow off Hwy 1 in all directions, and the left turns onto Hwy 1 could be tied into the existing intersections. It would have allowed for that truck parking area, too.

As mentioned, the big problem with that concept is the movement of trucks from NB Hwy 11 to WB Hwy 1. Gridlock is already an issue here, so having trucks lined up in a left turn lane would be suboptimal.

jakeroot

Quote from: TXtoNJ on April 13, 2026, 03:28:38 PM
Quote from: jakeroot on April 11, 2026, 12:55:26 AMI am surprised they're not building a partial cloverleaf of some kind. Specifically the B4 style with off-ramp loops. It would have allowed constant flow off Hwy 1 in all directions, and the left turns onto Hwy 1 could be tied into the existing intersections. It would have allowed for that truck parking area, too.

As mentioned, the big problem with that concept is the movement of trucks from NB Hwy 11 to WB Hwy 1. Gridlock is already an issue here, so having trucks lined up in a left turn lane would be suboptimal.

A double left turn with two-phase operations likely has the same capacity a single lane loop, especially one this tight.

A left turn on-ramp would also allow trucks substantially more time to reach highway speeds. The current design will have trucks slogging along worse than now even after merging onto the westbound carriageway.